Ask a Question

Ask a halacha question.

Rabbi Shay Tahan

Rabbi Shay Tahan and Bet Horaah Shaare Ezra answer quickly, accurately and confidentially — Sephardic, Ashkenazic or Chassidic.

4,163questions answered
2,329video classes
552articles
100weekly newsletters

Latest classes

All videos

Recent questions

All brachot
ShabbatEating the Shabbat Meal Earlier or Later

Should I eat the Shabbat day meal earlier or later than usual?

Answer: If eating earlier is a pleasure for him, for example because the night meal has already been digested, he should eat earlier; and if eating later is a pleasure for him, for example because it has not yet been digested, he should eat later. The Rema adds that someone who has meals every day like on Shabbat should change the time on Shabbat, either earlier or later. Reason: He changes…

Read the full answer → Eating the Shabbat Meal Earlier or Later
ShabbatMelave Malka on Motzaei Shabbat

Is there a meal on Motzaei Shabbat, and how much must one eat?

Answer: A person should always set his table on Motzaei Shabbat to escort Shabbat out, even if he needs only a kezayit (an olive’s volume). Reason: Just as one honors Shabbat when it arrives, one must honor it as it leaves, like escorting a king as he leaves the city.

Read the full answer → Melave Malka on Motzaei Shabbat
ShabbatAte Before Havdalah by Mistake

I ate on Motzaei Shabbat before making Havdalah. Can I still make Havdalah?

Answer: Yes. If one mistakenly ate before making Havdalah, he can make Havdalah afterwards.

Read the full answer → Ate Before Havdalah by Mistake
ShabbatDoes a Blind Person Say Borei Me’orei Ha’esh?

Does a blind person say the bracha on the fire at Havdalah?

Answer: No. A blind person does not say this bracha. Reason: The bracha requires benefiting from the light enough to tell coins apart, which does not apply to a blind person.

Read the full answer → Does a Blind Person Say Borei Me’orei Ha’esh?
TefillahNo Chazarat HaShatz at Arvit

Why doesn’t the chazan repeat the Amidah at Arvit?

Answer: The chazan does not repeat the Amidah at Arvit. The Rema adds that we do not say Tachanun (nefilat apayim) after Arvit. Reason: Arvit was originally not an obligation but only a mitzvah, so no one is obligated in it in a way that would require the chazan to fulfill it for him; and even though it was later accepted as an obligation, that custom is not strong enough to…

Read the full answer → No Chazarat HaShatz at Arvit
ShabbatHow Close to Stand to the Havdalah Candle

Do I need to be near the Havdalah candle for the bracha on the fire?

Answer: Yes. The bracha on the fire is not said until one can benefit from its light, meaning close enough to it to tell apart the coins of one country from those of another.

Read the full answer → How Close to Stand to the Havdalah Candle
ShabbatLooking at the Fingernails at Havdalah

Why do people look at their fingernails during the Havdalah bracha on the fire?

Answer: The custom is to look at the palms and fingernails. The Rema writes to look at the nails of the right hand while holding the cup in the left, bending the fingers into the palm so that the nails and palm are seen at once. Reason: The bracha on fire requires being able to benefit from its light, so one looks at the nails to see that he can distinguish…

Read the full answer → Looking at the Fingernails at Havdalah
ShabbatGoing Out With a Bandage on Shabbat

May I go outside on Shabbat with a bandage or dressing on a wound, where there is no eruv?

Answer: One may go out with cotton or a sponge on a wound, because they heal, so they are like an ornament; likewise with a medicated cloth, a poultice or a dressing on it. If it fell off, he may not put it back on, and all the more so he may not put it on to begin with. Reason: Putting it back is like putting it on to begin with,…

Read the full answer → Going Out With a Bandage on Shabbat

Have a question of your own?

Ask Rabbi Tahan. Your name and email are never published.

Ask Rabbi Tahan →

About Rabbi Shay Tahan

As the primary mover of the Beit Horaa, Rabbi Shay Tahan is very experienced and familiar with the world of halacha. He learned in the prestigious yeshiva Beit Shmaya and in Kiryat Malachi located in Eretz Yisrael. Rabbi Tahan continued on his path of learning Torah in the Mirrer Brooklyn for over the past 20 years. He received smicha from several Torah giants such as Rabbi Shmuel Birnbaum, Rabbi Yisroel Belsky, Rabbi Yechezkel Roth, Rabbi Avraham Nelkenbaum, and others. His achievements include receiving smicha as a sofer stam in both ktiva and hagaa from Rabbi Avraham Tzvi Wosner, shimush in Shaatnez, shimush in bug checking, and also specializes in leniencies in matters of birth contraception from Rabbi Tzvi Meisels. In addition, Rabbi Tahan gives shiurim on a variety of different topics.

Bet Horaah Shaare Ezra, under Rabbi Shay Tahan shlit"a — Rosh Kollel of Kollel Shaarei Ezra, Brooklyn — serves the community by answering halachic questions accurately, promptly and conveniently. Ask a question