Ask a Question

Chanukah Halachot in Short

Chanukah · from the Rav’s classes
הלכות חנוכה בקצרה
175 Chanukah halachot in short, from Rabbi Shay Tahan’s YouTube classes, written as he said them. Tap ▶ next to any halacha to watch him say it, at that minute of the class.
Who lights: women and children
1
Women are obligated in Chanukah lights just like men. A woman can light and be motzi the entire household.
2
A wife is yotzeh with her husband’s lighting and does not need her own candle. The husband can appoint her as his shliach to light for the household, but if he is home he should light.
3
A woman who lives alone must light herself.
4
A child should not light the main candle to be motzi the adults or household; the adult lights unless the child is alone. Some say a child of chinuch age can be motzi, but the halacha does not follow that view.
5
Sephardim (Shulchan Aruch) light one menorah per house, and everyone fulfills the mitzvah with it. The ruling that a katan must light refers to a child living alone in his own house.
6
Ashkenazim (Rambam/Rema): every member of the household lights his own menorah, adding a candle each night. A child of chinuch age (about 6-7, some say 7-8) should light, and a child of any age may light his own menorah.
7
Ashkenazim should place each person’s menorah somewhat apart from the others, as the Rema says, so it is clear which night it is.
8
A Sephardi child who wants to light his own menorah (e.g. one made in school) should not be stopped; it is even good. He lights without brachot, a little distance from the main menorah.
9
A Sephardi adult may not light an additional menorah, because he may not say the brachot on it.
10
According to the Ben Ish Chai and the Or LeZion, a child may not light the hiddur (additional) candles at all, since they are now viewed as an obligation.
11
According to Chacham Ovadia, a child may light the hiddur candles; one is strict only regarding the main candle.
12
Everyone agrees a child may light the shamash. According to Chacham Ovadia, the shamash has no kedusha, so there is no problem at all.
13
Women have a custom not to do work in their own house while the candles burn (the required half hour). Some, cited by the Mishna Brura, restrict men too, but the minhag is to allow men. Sephardim have no such custom for men at all.
14
The work women avoid is work forbidden on Chol HaMoed, such as laundry. Cooking and preparing food are permitted and even encouraged.
Guests, travelers and yeshiva students
15
According to the Shulchan Aruch (Sephardim), a guest does not light his own candle. He is yotzeh with the host by giving him a peruta, which makes him a partner in the oil and the mitzvah.
16
According to the Rema (Ashkenazim), a guest may either be yotzeh with the host or light his own menorah.
17
According to the Mishna Brura, the guest does not have to pay. The host can give him part of the oil as a gift with a kinyan, such as the guest picking it up.
18
A guest needs to partner with the host only if no one lights for him at home. If his wife lights at home, he is yotzeh with her lighting.
19
According to the Mishna Brura, a guest who is unsure whether someone is lighting for him at home should light his own candles.
20
According to the Mishna Brura, if he later learns that his wife already lit for him, he must still light his own menorah with a bracha, since he did not have her lighting in mind.
21
A guest with his own entrance, such as a basement apartment, must light at his own door or window because of chashad, even though he is yotzeh with the host.
22
A Sephardi yeshiva boy whose parents light at home is yotzeh with their lighting and does not need to light.
23
According to the Rema, someone away from home who is among Jews and sees their candles may light his own menorah with a bracha to be stringent. This is the custom.
Time of lighting
24
According to the Shulchan Aruch, as explained by the Magen Avraham and brought by the Mishna Brura, one lights at the end of shkia, meaning tzeit hakochavim. L’chatchila light exactly then, not before and not after.
25
If one did not light exactly at tzeit hakochavim, he has up to half an hour after that to light.
26
The halacha does not follow the Rambam, who holds that after half an hour one no longer lights with a bracha. Still, be very careful to light exactly on time to satisfy his opinion.
27
According to Tosfot, one should light right away at the beginning of the night, so the candles burn during that first half hour.
28
If one did not light at shkiya, he may still light until people stop walking in the street, which is half an hour.
29
The Rema says that even today, when we light indoors, one should l’chatchila light at the beginning of the night. However, it is easier nowadays to rely on the leniency of lighting later.
30
If the half hour has passed, one may still light the whole night until alot hashachar, even right before it. He should put in enough oil to last half an hour.
31
Once the night passes without lighting, that night’s mitzvah is lost and cannot be made up.
32
Those who follow Rabbeinu Tam’s second shkia light at that time, 58 and a half minutes after sunset.
33
Someone who keeps Rabbeinu Tam’s time all year may light on Motzaei Shabbat after Rabbeinu Tam’s time, even though it is much later.
34
If one cannot light on time, not even at shkia, the Shulchan Aruch allows lighting from Plag HaMincha. According to the Mishna Brura, Plag is 1 hour and 15 minutes (in shaot zmaniot) before tzeit hakochavim.
35
Lighting at Plag HaMincha applies only when one cannot light at tzeit hakochavim at all. Many poskim say this is not l’maaseh and one should not light at Plag at all.
36
If he missed lighting before praying, he should still pray on time, since tefillah and kriyat shema are tadir, and light right afterwards. If possible, he should prepare the candles beforehand.
Where to put the menorah, and how high
37
If safety is not a concern, there are two options: a window facing outside, which is the minhag, or by the door within the height measurements.
38
In America the minhag is to light by the window. If no window faces the public domain, one may light on the table.
39
In Eretz Yisrael many light outside, in the front yard or by the front door facing outside, so the public sees it (Rav Elyashiv and many poskim).
40
L’chatchila the menorah goes outside at the opening to the public domain. If the house opens straight onto the street, place it at the house opening. If there is a front yard, place it at the opening of the yard.
41
Chacham Ovadia (also Or Letzion): today’s decorative front yard is not a chatzer, so light at the door of the house.
42
Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach: today’s front yards are like those of the past, so light at the opening of the front yard.
43
On an upper floor with no opening to the public domain, place the menorah in a window facing the public domain.
44
In a time of danger, when one cannot light outside or by the window, lighting on one’s table inside is enough. Many poskim say ‘sakana’ includes anything that hinders the mitzvah, such as wind.
45
By the door, the flame must be above 3 tefachim and below 10 tefachim (a tefach is 8 cm). According to Kabbalah (Ben Ish Chai), it should be between 7 and 10 tefachim.
46
The heights are measured from the flame, not from the menorah (Minchat Yitzchak, Rav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach).
47
A tefach is 8 cm according to Rav Avraham Chaim Naeh and 10 cm according to the Chazon Ish.
48
Most height rules are l’chatchila; b’dieved, above 10 tefachim one is yotzeh. Above 20 amot it is not valid at all.
49
The 3 to 10 tefachim rule applies only when placing it on the floor by the door. By the window, the height makes no difference.
50
Some say that lighting indoors on a window or table higher than 10 tefachim is fine, but many are still makpid on the Gemara’s height.
51
At the doorway, the menorah must be within a tefach of the opening. The Mishna Brura says the whole menorah should be within that tefach.
52
According to the Arizal, the menorah is placed outside the door. According to the Mishna Brura (Chayei Adam), it is placed within the opening.
53
At the doorway, place it on the left, opposite the mezuzah. Anywhere in the left half is valid, but as far left as possible is best (Mishna Brura).
54
If there is no mezuzah, place the menorah on the right side.
55
According to the Rema, those lighting inside (window or table) need not worry about left or right.
56
Light the menorah where it will stay. If you light it and then move it (e.g. inside to outside), you are not yotzeh. If lit above 20 amot, lowering it later does not help (Rema).
57
If the menorah is already standing in its place, just light it there. There is no need to lift it and set it down again.
58
Lighting while holding the menorah does not work. According to the Taz, this applies only if he holds it the whole half hour; other poskim require it to already rest in its place.
59
If you lit in a windy place where you know it will go out, you must relight.
60
According to the Shulchan Aruch, a house with openings on two different sides lights at both. If both doors are on the same side, one is enough.
61
According to the Rema (Mishna Brura), nowadays one opening is enough, even for those lighting at the door.
62
According to the Rema, each household member places his candles in a separate spot, so it is clear what night it is and how many are lighting.
63
It is a very good idea to put a tray under the menorah for chashivut.
How many candles, and the order
64
By the letter of the law, the mitzvah is one candle per night for the household. Mehadrin light one per person in the house, and mehadrin min ha-mehadrin light according to the number of the night.
65
Sephardim follow the Shulchan Aruch, based on Tosfot: one menorah for the household according to the night (one, two, three…). They do not add candles for the number of people in the house.
66
We light according to the night: one candle the first night, adding one each night. We do not light eight every night.
67
On the first night, place the candle on the far right of the menorah. On later nights, place all the candles on the right side.
68
According to the Shulchan Aruch, from the second night on, start with the newly added leftmost candle and continue to the right. The bracha is said on that new candle.
69
According to the Taz and the Gra, always start with the rightmost candle, since it is the main mitzvah and closest to the doorway.
70
When the menorah is on a table or by a window, so the tefach from the door is not an issue, the halacha l’maaseh is always to start from the left and go right.
71
Stand in front of the candle you light first. Do not stand at the right and reach over the closer candles, because of ein maavirin al hamitzvot.
72
Say the brachot first, then light. Haneirot Halalu is said after lighting the first candle, while lighting the rest, which are hiddur mitzvah.
73
Place the shamash apart from the menorah so it is clear how many candles are being lit. It may be somewhat higher, so any benefit from the light comes from the shamash.
74
Candles should be in a straight line, not in a circle (Rema), and not in a zigzag (Mishna Brura), since these look like a bonfire. A circle is permitted if the candles are at least a finger’s width apart.
75
One oil vessel with two openings may serve as two candles, even for mehadrin who light per person (Rema, Mishna Brura).
76
Even if one missed lighting one night, he lights on the following nights like everyone else.
77
A poor person is only required to light one candle each night that lasts half an hour. According to the Petach Einayim, one should go beyond the minimum.
78
According to the Magen Avraham, if a friend lacks even one candle for the basic mitzvah, give him your extra hiddur candles rather than lighting them yourself.
Brachot and how to light
79
If on the second or third night he comes to light himself, he does not say Shehecheyanu again (reading the Shulchan Aruch).
80
According to the Magen Avraham, if someone (e.g. his wife) lights at home on his behalf, he does not say She’asa Nissim or Shehecheyanu when seeing candles, because her brachot exempt him. He also does not say Shehecheyanu on later nights, even though he never said it himself.
81
One who chooses to be strict and relight a candle that went out, though not obligated, should not say a bracha.
82
According to the Mishna Brura, one who lights early from Plag HaMincha says the bracha, even though it is before shkia.
83
According to the Rema, when lighting menorahs at two openings, you light both but say the bracha on only one.
84
On the first night, say three brachot: Lehadlik Ner Chanukah, She’asa Nissim La’avoteinu, and Shehecheyanu. From the second night on, say only the first two.
85
Finish all the brachot before you begin lighting.
86
After lighting the first candle, say Haneirot Halalu. You may light the shamash while saying it.
87
After lighting, finish with Mizmor Shir Chanukat HaBayit.
Oil, wicks and candles
88
One must put enough oil in the menorah to burn for half an hour.
89
When lighting early from Plag HaMincha, put in enough oil to burn until half an hour after nightfall. Otherwise there is no pirsum hanes.
90
On Erev Shabbat, put in enough oil to burn from lighting until half an hour after Tzet HaKochavim.
91
Any oil and any wick may be used for Chanukah, unlike Shabbat, even if they don’t burn well, since one need not relight if it goes out.
92
According to the Rema, olive oil is the choicest, since it lights best and was used in the Beit HaMikdash.
93
The mitzvah is the lighting. If the candle goes out within the half hour, one need not relight it.
94
If it went out while you were fixing it within the half hour, you are not obligated to relight it. Fixing it is a hiddur mitzvah.
95
According to the Mishna Brura, this exemption applies only if lit where it would normally burn half an hour. If lit in a windy place knowing it would go out, one must relight.
96
A used earthenware lamp becomes ‘old’ and disgusting, so it should not be used again another night. Use new ones each night.
97
Metal or glass lamps, or coated clay lamps, may be reused, since they don’t absorb oil.
98
Wicks do not need to be new each night. The same wicks may be reused.
99
A bowl of oil with several wicks around it is invalid, since it burns like a bonfire. It is valid only if each wick is covered separately and the wicks are a finger’s width apart.
100
The Shulchan Aruch says to be very careful with this mitzvah. The Pele Yoetz explains this as using nice candles or good oil and a nice menorah.
101
Since Chanukah candles publicize the miracle, one may spend beyond the usual fifth for them, like the four cups on Pesach.
102
A poor person should sell clothing or collect money for candles. Otherwise the city’s tzedaka fund should provide them.
103
When lighting, hold the flame to the wick until the wick catches.
104
According to the Rema (Darkei Moshe), there is no hiddur in long candles at home, since they only need to burn half an hour.
105
The halacha follows the Magen Avraham: with wax candles, long candles are a nicer mitzvah. With oil, only half an hour’s worth is needed, since extra oil is no hiddur.
Using the light, the shamash and leftover oil
106
If you put in more oil than needed, you may extinguish the menorah once the half hour has passed.
107
Per the Shulchan Aruch, oil left after the candles burned for half an hour may be used for anything, such as a salad or other light.
108
The Mishna Brura gives one explanation: if one put the oil in without specifying, all of it becomes muktze for the mitzvah. If he intended it only for the half hour, he may use the leftover oil after the half hour.
109
L’chatchila, before lighting, make a tnai (as the Bach says) that you will use whatever oil is left over. One tnai on the first day covers all eight days.
110
Oil from a candle that went out within the first half hour (e.g. wind or a child) stays designated for the mitzvah and may not be reused. If it is still Chanukah, put it in the menorah the next night and burn it.
111
Designated oil left after the eighth night must be burned by itself in a fire. Do not pour it into the sink or toilet or throw it in the garbage, because that is bizui mitzvah.
112
One may not use the light of the Chanukah candles, e.g. to count money or check a coin, even from far away.
113
Per the Rema, after the half hour one may benefit from the light of the Chanukah candles.
114
A shamash is lit because one may not use the Chanukah light. If there is other light nearby, such as electricity, it is not needed. However, a distinguished person who does not use that light should put up a shamash.
115
Per the Shulchan Aruch, some light an extra candle besides the shamash, placed away from the menorah. Per the Magen Avraham, even then one should not use the menorah’s light l’chatchila.
116
Per the Shulchan Aruch, one may not light one Chanukah candle from another by way of a ner chol. Some permit an extra candle used for the mitzvah, unless it may go out before the second candle is lit.
117
One may light one Chanukah candle directly from another, e.g. with a long wick; per most Poskim this is the correct way. Per the Taz (cited by the Mishna Brura), one may also pick up a candle, light the other, and put it right back.
118
The prohibition of lighting one candle from another applies only within the half hour. After that, one may light from one to another.
119
A lit Chanukah candle (within its half hour) that got mixed with other candles is not nullified, even one in a thousand (davar shel minyan). The solution is to light enough of them that a permitted candle is surely burning; then one may use them.
120
The Shulchan Aruch permits lighting one Chanukah candle from another. The Rema says the custom today is not to, since only the first candle is the essential mitzvah and the rest are hiddur.
121
Shulchan Aruch: all mitzvah candles (shul, Shabbat, Chanukah) have the same kedusha, so one may light from one to another.
Lighting in shul and at events
122
In shul the menorah is lit between Mincha and Arvit, when people are present, with a beracha, following the Shulchan Aruch. Even though it is only a minhag, the beracha is said because of pirsumei nisa.
123
On Erev Shabbat some light in shul before Mincha so there is enough time before Shabbat.
124
If there is no time and the congregation wants to pray right away, start the lighting yourself. The shamash or the person in charge of the shul then lights the rest of the candles during the prayer.
125
In shul the menorah is placed on the south side, set east to west like the menorah in the Beit HaMikdash.
126
As the Rema says, the person who lit in shul must light again at home.
127
The beracha applies only to a shul where they regularly pray Mincha and Arvit. A minyan set up in an office for Chanukah lights without a beracha, since it is not a Bet HaKnesset.
128
At a Chanukah party in a hotel, hall or similar place, it is nice to light the menorah, but without a beracha. Chacham Ovadia was somewhat lenient to allow a beracha, but since it is a real safek, apply safek berachot lehakel and follow the majority of poskim.
129
In shul the mitzvah is for the candles to burn all day, so longer candles there are a hiddur mitzvah.
Erev Shabbat, Shabbat and Motzaei Shabbat
130
According to the Shulchan Aruch, once Chanukah candles are lit you may not benefit from them, so they cannot be used for the havdala bracha on fire (me’orei ha’esh).
131
Mishna Brura citing the Bach: someone with only one candle should first use it for havdala, then extinguish it and light it for Chanukah. This is even preferable, since an item used for one mitzvah should be used for another.
132
In shul on Motzaei Shabbat, the Chanukah menorah is lit first and havdala is made afterwards.
133
According to the Rema, at home one also lights the menorah first and then makes havdala.
134
Poskim brought by the Mishna Brura hold that at home havdala comes first because it is tadir, and then the menorah is lit. This is the Sephardi minhag according to most Sephardi poskim.
135
The Mishna Brura says each person should follow his own custom on the order of havdala and the menorah at home.
136
On Erev Shabbat, light the Chanukah candles first and then the Shabbat candles. This satisfies all opinions.
137
On Erev Shabbat, say the bracha on the Chanukah candles as usual, even though they are lit while it is still day.
138
The earliest time to light Chanukah candles on Erev Shabbat is Plag HaMincha, an hour and fifteen minutes before night.
139
If you lit before Shabbat with enough oil for half an hour after nightfall and it went out, you do not have to relight, even though it is not yet Shabbat.
140
If the menorah is by the door on Shabbat, put something between the candles and the opening so the wind does not blow them out when the door opens.
141
On Erev Shabbat, do not attach the candles to the door itself, because opening and closing it moves the flame and oil.
142
According to the Rema, on Shabbat such inferior wicks and oils may be used only if they contain just enough to burn for half an hour. After that the light may be used, so we fear one may come to tilt it.
143
Per the Gemara, if one has money for only one candle, he should buy a Shabbat candle rather than a Chanukah candle, because of shalom bayit.
144
The Mishna Brura cites poskim that today, since the Chanukah candle is lit inside the house, one should buy the Chanukah candle instead. Many poskim say this applies even more today, since electric light covers Shabbat.
145
According to the Shulchan Aruch, if one can afford only a Chanukah candle or wine for Kiddush, he should buy the Chanukah candle and make Kiddush on bread.
146
If one can afford only a Chanukah candle or wine for Havdala, he should buy the Chanukah candle, because of pirsumei nisa.
147
With limited means, one Shabbat candle is enough instead of two, and the rest go to Chanukah. For example, on the sixth night light one for Shabbat and six for Chanukah.
148
Making food crunchy on the hot plate is not makeh b’patish. Most poskim, including Or LeTzion and Chacham Ovadia, hold there is no makeh b’patish with food.
149
Do not put a jelly-filled sufganiya on the hot plate on Shabbat, since the jelly usually contains uncooked water that would get cooked. This is forbidden even according to Chacham Ovadia’s lenient view on a minority of liquid.
Hallel
150
On Chanukah, Hallel is said with a bracha.
151
Be careful to pronounce the words of Hallel correctly. A word said wrongly in a way that changes its meaning does not count.
152
Citing the Shaar HaTziyun: if one skips even one word or one verse of Hallel, he has not fulfilled the obligation and must go back.
153
Citing the Noda BiYehuda: do not break up the words of Hallel, for example while shaking or singing. Stretching a word is fine as long as it stays connected.
Meals and donuts
154
According to the Shulchan Aruch, the extra meals on Chanukah are optional (seudot reshut). The days were set for Hallel and thanksgiving, not for feasting and rejoicing like Purim.
155
The Rema says there is some mitzvah in having extra meals on Chanukah, because the Chanukat Hamizbeach took place in those days.
156
The custom is to say songs and praises at Chanukah meals. According to the Mishna Brura, the day alone or the Torah and songs alone do not make it a seudat mitzvah, but together they do. So one should take care to say Torah or songs and praises at the meal.
157
The Rema cites those who say to eat cheese (dairy) on Chanukah, because the miracle came through the milk Yehudit fed the enemy.
158
According to the Shulchan Aruch, a yerei shamayim should eat fried donuts only within a bread meal, after first making HaMotzi on regular bread.
159
According to the Rema, the custom is to be lenient like Rabbeinu Shimshon, so Ashkenazim say mezonot on donuts (sufganiyot).
160
According to the Or LeTzion and Rabbi David Yosef, the Shulchan Aruch’s main ruling is mezonot on donuts. The stringency is only for a yerei shamayim. Per the Or LeTzion, the after-bracha is Al HaMichya even when eating many, and only one who wants to be stringent eats them within a bread meal.
161
According to Chacham Ovadia, a donut is treated as cooked for brachot. One never says HaMotzi or Birkat HaMazon on donuts, even when eating a large amount.
162
Even a yerei shamayim may say mezonot on donuts eaten as a snack and not as a meal, especially since the dough is sweet and often filled with jelly.
163
Bottom line: say mezonot on sufganiyot, and Al HaMichya after, even if you eat a large amount.
164
According to Chacham Ovadia, for bishul akum a donut is treated as baked, so the leniencies of pat akum apply. Ashkenazim, following the Rema, may buy from a non-Jewish bakery with a hechsher. Sephardim are stricter, following the Shulchan Aruch.
165
If a non-Jewish worker puts the donuts into the oil, they may still be eaten, since they are treated as baked rather than fried. This follows the rule of pat Yisrael according to Rabbeinu Tam’s view.
Safety, gifts, buying a menorah
166
If there are children in the house, make sure the menorah, by the window or the door, is in a safe place where they cannot get hurt.
167
With children around, do not rely on ‘shluchei mitzvah einam nizokim’. It applies only where harm is not likely, and with kids harm is likely.
168
If you can afford only one candle, either for Chanukah or for Shabbat, buy for Shabbat, because shalom bayit comes first.
169
Chanukah’s eight days begin on 25 Kislev. Eulogies and fasting are forbidden, but melacha is permitted.
170
Making a seven-branched menorah of any metal (not only gold) is forbidden in any size. This applies even without knobs, cups and flowers and even under 18 tefachim; five, six or eight branches are fine.
171
A seven-branched menorah of wood, earthenware or other non-metal material is permitted.
172
Some permit owning a seven-branched menorah made by a non-Jew. Rav Elyashiv ruled one may not even own one, since it is a Torah prohibition.
173
When buying a metal menorah, make sure it does not have seven branches. If you already own one, cut off a branch, add one if you can, or dispose of it.
174
Chanukah gifts to children are not forbidden as bechukoteihem, since the reason is to make them happy. However, there is no Jewish source for gifts, so whether to give them is a hashkafa question for one’s Rav.
175
There is a source for giving Chanukah gelt to children. It gives them simchat hachag and encourages them.
Nothing found. Try another word, or watch the full classes below.
Every halacha above is from a class of Rabbi Shay Tahan, with the video at the minute he says it. Full classes: the Chanuka playlist on YouTube. Have a question? Ask Rabbi Tahan.