Parashat Bamidbar opens with Hashem commanding Moshe Rabbenu to count the people, and Rashi explains that Hakadosh Baruch Hu counts them out of His great love for them. But when does He count them? Precisely at the moments when Am Yisrael fell to the lowest levels. Let us look at this Rashi, together with a surprising Rashi at the end of last week’s parasha, and we will see that the Torah is teaching us how to treat a person who has fallen, a lesson that touches one of the most painful problems of our generation.
Love at the Lowest Moment?
The pasuk says: וידבר ה’ אל משה במדבר סיני באהל מועד באחד לחדש השני… שאו את ראש כל עדת בני ישראל. Count them. Rashi says: מתוך חבתם לפניו מונה אותם כל שעה, because they are so dear to Him, He counts them all the time. Every moment He has a chance, He counts them. When did He count them? When they came out of Mitzrayim, and when they fell with the Egel Hazahav, and so on.
So I was reading this Rashi, and there is a simple question. Hashem loves them so much that He counts them. When? When Yisrael went to the highest level of sinning. When they came out of Mitzrayim, they were at מ”ט שערי טומאה, the forty-nine gates of impurity. What do you want worse than that? And at the Egel, you just gave them the Torah and they are making an Egel! The Malachim were saying, so to speak, this is the time to get rid of them, say goodbye, get a new nation.
The Rambam explains in Hilchot Teshuvah that a person who sins is not loved by Hakadosh Baruch Hu, and he calls such a person all kinds of names. A person who does teshuvah, Hakadosh Baruch Hu loves him. So what does it mean here? They just did the Egel Hazahav. Why are you rewarding them now with chibah, with such love?
The Strange Warning in Parashat Behar
If we go back to last week’s parasha, Parashat Behar, at the end of the parasha there is an interesting Rashi. The pesukim there warn that one may not worship avodah zarah, one may not be mechalel Shabbat, and one may not violate giluy arayot. Rashi asks, why do we need all these warnings here? And he explains: we are talking about a person who is now sold as a slave to a non-Jew. He should not say, just as my master worships idols, so will I; just as my master is megaleh arayot, so will I; just as my master is mechalel Shabbat, so will I. So the Torah comes and says no. Don’t do that.
I was reading this Rashi, and it is unbelievable. The Torah needs to warn this person that he is not allowed to do these things, which means there was a hava amina that maybe he is allowed. What kind of thought is that? These are the worst sins of the Torah: giluy arayot, shefichut damim, avodah zarah and chilul Shabbat, the worst of the worst. Would a person really think that since his master is doing it, he is also allowed? Very strange that the Torah needs to warn him.
A Person Who Lost Everything
If you look at the pesukim a little beforehand, you will see that the Torah is not really speaking to the person sold as a slave. The Torah speaks to every Jew except him. The Torah says, when your brother becomes poor, he sells himself, and so on. First he is sold to a Jew, and eventually he could be sold to a non-Jew, to an oved avodah zarah.
What happened to this person? Slowly, slowly, he had a breakdown. In the beginning he had a business that was flourishing, a family, a community. He would go out every day and feel good. Slowly, slowly things were sold, everything became devastated, until he came to the point that he was sold to a non-Jew. And therefore the Torah says, make sure not to let him stay there. You must redeem him, buy him back, and there is a list of who has to do it; the relatives are obligated first to try to redeem him.
Such a person, who came to the lowest point, eventually goes into ye’ush, despair, depression. He reaches the stage where he says, just like my master is doing these things, I’m giving up, I’ll do exactly like him. That is a point of ye’ush where there is nothing left to lose; he is not thinking anymore. The Torah does not speak to the one who fell into ye’ush. The Torah speaks to us. The Torah tells us: make sure he doesn’t come to that stage, and if he did, make sure to save him.
Before the Burden Falls
The Torah points this out throughout last week’s parasha: whenever a person is coming to a stage where he is going to crumble and fall, hold him. Rashi brings a mashal of a camel, or a donkey, walking with a heavy burden and ready to fall. While it is still standing, one person can give it some support and it will be able to walk further. But once it falls down, even five people cannot pick it up.
What is Rashi telling us? Before a person falls, if you help him out, you can give him that support. But once he has fallen, there is a crumbling effect, not only on him but also on his family, his wife, his children. Imagine such a person in a state of ye’ush. His wife can’t cope anymore. His children can’t go to school and feel like normal human beings. His relatives can’t feel well. Everything starts falling apart, and that is the state where five people can’t pick him up. So the Torah says, before he falls, give him that support.
The Plague of Our Generation
This Rashi and these pesukim are so much noge’a to us. Today, unfortunately, we have a plague around the world, not only in Brooklyn, not only in Lakewood or Monsey, and that is what we call OTD, kids who go off the derech.
Many people think the reason is the Internet: how can you fight the Internet, once a person falls into it he is lost. But the professionals in the field, who deal with these kids day in and day out, say it has nothing to do with the Internet or anything like that. The reason kids fall apart is that today they have become very sensitive to abuse at an early age. When a child is abused, or falls into depression at an early age, when people misbehaved toward him in all kinds of ways, it comes back in the teenage years. That is the cause, and the effect is that later these kids fall apart. It is devastating; they no longer respond to anything of Yiddishkeit, anything of religion.
This is what the Torah comes to tell us. Once a person falls, once a child falls, there is only one cure. You can’t give him mussar. A person who has given up on everything, kids who are cutting themselves, kids on drugs, kids going through the worst of the worst, you can’t give them mussar. The only thing that can support such a child is to give him the feeling of love: we are still connected to you, we still love you, you are still important to us. When a person feels that way, eventually, after the teenage years when the hormones go crazy, he comes back to himself. This is how the professionals in the field look at it, and this is also how the Torah views this new problem of our generation.
Counting Them Out of Love
Now we understand the Rashi at the opening of Sefer Bamidbar. מתוך חבתם לפניו מונה אותם. When they are at the lowest degree, at the forty-nine gates of impurity, that is exactly when one might say, throw them out. That’s what the Malachim said. You know how some think you should treat an OTD kid? Throw him out of the house. And the Malachim said, say goodbye, get a new nation. Then at the Egel, the worst of the worst, right after receiving the Torah, get rid of them. Hakadosh Baruch Hu says, on the contrary. The way you treat such a person is that you count them; you show them love.
This is what the Torah tells us in Parashat Behar and at the beginning of Parashat Bamidbar, and it is something we must take home. This plague is all over; you can’t miss it. Whenever we see a person who has fallen, a child who has gone off the derech, this is the way to treat him: hold him before he falls, and if he has fallen, show him love and connection, and eventually, with Hashem’s help, he will come back up.
Based on a class by Rabbi Shay Tahan, “OTD Treatment” (Parashat Bechukotai): watch the class on TorahAnytime.
