Ask a Question

Two Patients, One Doctor vs. Two Doctors, One Patient: A Tale of Contrasts

Rabbi Shay Tahan

While the unrest in university protests is undeniably concerning, some actually perceive it as a positive development. Let me explain why.

If we examine our Torah portion (Kedoshim), we repeatedly encounter warnings that certain sins warrant the punishment of death. A friend once posed a question to me: why does the Torah need to continually use such harsh language to threaten punishment? The answer can be found in the first commentary of Rashi on the beginning of the previous Torah portion (Acharei Mot). Hashem warns Aaron not to enter the Holy of Holies at all times, lest he die. Rashi raises the question: Why was it necessary to include the warning of death?

Rashi provides an analogy to elucidate this point: Imagine a sick person visited by two doctors. The first doctor advises against consuming certain foods, while the second doctor reinforces the warning by saying, "Do not eat them, lest you die like another sick person did." In essence, the second doctor adds a threat to ensure the sick person takes the instructions seriously. Similarly, Hashem warns Aaron's descendants to underscore the gravity of the situation and to emphasize that failure to heed the warning carries real danger. Hashem wanted to ensure their compliance by impressing upon them the severity of the consequences.

Many times, problems go unnoticed because they aren't immediately visible, quietly festering beneath the surface until they become too advanced to treat effectively. It's crucial to recognize and address these issues before they escalate. Across the world, terrorists are gradually infiltrating US cities, a danger that's often overlooked. With each passing day, the threat grows more ominous. If left unchecked, it could reach a point where intervention is no longer effective. The recent surge in riots and so-called "protests" serves as a wake-up call, highlighting the symptoms of a larger problem that demands attention before it's too late.

Another scenario highlighted by Rashi (Parashat Shmini) involves a doctor visiting two patients. Upon seeing the first patient, the doctor refrains from prescribing any treatment. However, upon encountering the second patient, the doctor provides detailed instructions on diet and medical procedures. When questioned about this discrepancy, the doctor explains that the first patient's illness has progressed to an advanced stage beyond cure, rendering any treatment ineffective. As a result, the first patient is advised to live out their remaining days as they wish. Conversely, the second patient's condition is treatable, albeit requiring harsh measures to achieve recovery. This analogy illustrates the critical point at which a problem becomes incurable, underscoring the urgency of addressing issues before they reach this stage.

Drawing a parallel to current world events, we can liken Europe to the fatally incurable patient, as their situation appears beyond repair. On the other hand, America stands as a patient whose condition, if treated promptly, could be reversed before reaching the point of no return. This is precisely why these protests hold such significance—they thrust the issue into the spotlight, showcasing the potential risks of neglecting immediate intervention.