Ask a Question

Checking Broccoli and Cauliflower for Bugs

Question

What are the halachot about eating broccoli and cauliflower? How can I make them kosher (check them for bugs)?

Answer

It’s very hard; buy them only with a good hechsher.

Sources

The Torah forbids eating creatures that swarm on the earth: “they shall not be eaten.” This is why vegetables that tend to harbor insects are a real kashrut concern. The Shulchan Aruch rules that any produce that commonly becomes infested may not be eaten until it has been checked. The Rema adds that it is not enough to check most of it; everything must be checked, because the infested minority is common.

Thoroughly checking every floret of broccoli or cauliflower is very difficult. That is why the Rabbi advises buying them only with a reliable hechsher.

  • Leviticus 11:41 — all things that swarm upon the earth are an abomination and may not be eaten
  • Shulchan Aruch, Yoreh De’ah 84:8 — produce that commonly gets wormy may not be eaten without checking; Rema: one must check all of it, not just the majority, since the infestation is a common minority

Author

Rabbi Shay Tahan

Have a question of your own?

Ask Rabbi Tahan

More on Kashrut

KashrutDairy Plate Used for a Meat Sandwich

A dairy plate was accidentally used for a meat sandwich. What are the next steps for cleaning or kashering it?

Answer: Wash it.

Read the full answer → Dairy Plate Used for a Meat Sandwich
KashrutDairy Silicone Ladle Used in Pareve Soup in a Meat Pot

A dairy silicone soup ladle was placed in a fleishig pot with hot soup; the soup itself was pareve. Do I need to throw away the ladle?

Answer: Wash it.

Read the full answer → Dairy Silicone Ladle Used in Pareve Soup in a Meat Pot
KashrutHot Oven Pan Placed on an Unkashered Countertop

A hot aluminum pan with food in it was taken out of the oven and by mistake put directly on a countertop that was not kashered after the previous owners and may have been used for hot non-kosher food. The pan was then put back into the oven, which was on the whole time with other food cooking in it.…

Answer: If the counter was clean, then all is fine.

Read the full answer → Hot Oven Pan Placed on an Unkashered Countertop
Tevilat KeilimHagalah and Tevilat Kelim on Silverware From a Non-Jew

Can I do hagalah on silverware that came from a non-Jew or never had tevilat kelim? If so, do I have to do tevilat kelim after the hagalah?

Answer: Do hagalah first and then tevilah.

Read the full answer → Hagalah and Tevilat Kelim on Silverware From a Non-Jew
KashrutEggs Made in a Meat Pan With Milk Coffee

Am I allowed to eat eggs that were made in a fleishig (meat) pan and drink coffee with milk at the same time?

Answer: Yes, you may eat eggs made in a meat pan and drink coffee with milk at the same time.

Read the full answer → Eggs Made in a Meat Pan With Milk Coffee
KashrutDoes Bitter Nail Polish for Nail-Biting Babies Need to Be Kosher?

Does the bitter-tasting nail polish put on babies’ fingernails to stop them from biting their nails need to be kosher?

Answer: No, the bitter nail polish for babies who bite their nails does not need to be kosher.

Read the full answer → Does Bitter Nail Polish for Nail-Biting Babies Need to Be Kosher?